Katie Burke (Holmes) is a college senior who's having a tough time keeping herself focused. Haunted by memories of her boyfriend Embry (Hunnam), who disappeared two years earlier, she’s forced to relive the trauma after a detective, Wade Handler (Bratt), re-opens the case. As Katie struggles to finish school and secure a job with a prestigious firm, Embry suddenly returns. The mystery deepens after Handler's investigation reveals Embry's disappearance could be connected to other cases of missing students.